[Organic Chemicals] Which MMA (methyl methacrylate) production process is more competitive?
Different production processes lead to big gaps in the cost of making the same chemical, and that shapes how the competition plays out. China's MMA market now has nearly six production processes, and all six have reached industrial scale. In the Chinese market, the competitive situation varies a lot from one process to another.
The main MMA production processes are the acetone cyanohydrin (ACH) route, the ethylene carbonylation route, and the isobutylene oxidation (C4) route. From these three, several variants have emerged: an improved ACH process, the glacial acetic acid process, and processes named after the companies behind them, BASF and Lucite. All six have units of 10,000 tons per year or more running in China.
One thing worth pointing out: in September 2022, a 10,000-ton-scale industrial demonstration unit for making MMA from coal-based methanol and acetic acid, developed by the Institute of Process Engineering under the Chinese Academy of Sciences, started up successfully and ran steadily, with product meeting spec. It was the world's first coal-based methanol-acetic acid MMA demonstration plant, shifting domestic MMA production from relying entirely on petroleum feedstock to using coal-based feedstock.
Because the competitive landscape has shifted, the supply-demand environment for MMA has changed too, which has kept prices from running strong. Over the past two years, China's MMA market price has moved in a narrow range, with a high of 14,014 yuan/ton and a low of about 10,000 yuan/ton. As of August 2023, the price was around 11,500 yuan/ton.
The main downstream product is PMMA, and most companies develop along the MMA-PMMA chain. PMMA prices have been weak and choppy over the past two years, with a high of 17,560 yuan/ton and a low of 14,625 yuan/ton. As of August 2023, the mainstream price was fluctuating around 14,600 yuan/ton. Note that domestic PMMA is mostly mid- to low-end grades, so its price runs below imported material.
The industry generally agrees that the choice of MMA process determines the competitiveness of the MMA-PMMA chain. Comparing costs across processes, past and present, here's what stands out:
First, leaving aside the acetic acid process, the ethylene-based MMA process has been the most competitive over the past two years. From 2020 to August 2023, among the different processes, ethylene-based MMA had the lowest cost and the strongest competitiveness. Its theoretical cost was 5,530 yuan/ton in 2020, and the average for January-July 2023 was only 6,088 yuan/ton.
Comments
0